JP Arencibia Receives Johnny Bench Comp

With the recent release of 2011 Pecota projections, let’s check out the 2011 Projections on J.P. Arencibia.

While I don’t want to break down all of the specifics of each system (read official explanation: Pecota & Zips & Marcel), one of the bigger differences is Pectoa & Zips are park adjusted, Marcel is not.

Projections Table


Pecota is bullish on JP Arencibia. I could live with a .483 SLG & 26 bombs. Pecota included three comps. The first is Jake Fox, the third is Matthew Brown (essentially a career minor leaguer). The middle man? Johnny Bench. I’m not getting my hopes up but cool comp.


Johnny Bench:

Final AAA Season: 365 AB, 23 HR, .259/.301/.520, 21 BB, 68 K
First MLB Cup of Coffee: 86 AB, .163/.207/.256, 5 BB, 19 K

J.P. Arencibia:

Final AAA Season (hopefully): 459 AB, 32 HR, .301/.359/.626, 38 BB, 85 K
First MLB Cup of Coffee: 35 AB, .143/.189/.343, 2 BB, 11 K

Major Caveats: Defense, Bench (19) vs Arenciba (24) in ‘coffee’ seasons


Arencibia will struggle according to Zips, striking out 142 times and posting a sub-par OPS+ of 86. The HR will be present, although projected batting average & on-base percentage end up being the lowest of the three projection systems.


Marcel gives JPA fewer overall AB (196). This systems BB – K rate is drastically different than the others, predicating 18 BB vs 42 K. This is bullish. In limited duty, JPA walked only 2 times vs 11 K last season in 37 AB, along with a substantial minor league track record (96 BB vs 356 K)


With organizational offensive catching alternatives being non-existent (at least until D’Arnaud is ready), I could live with the ZIPs projection for JPA’s 2011 season. Although, I’d obviously prefer Pecota’s outcome, sprinkled in with a little Johnny Bench behind the dish. A guy can dream, can’t he?

What’s your projection for JPA in 2011? Will he over or under perform the sabermetrical projections? Which projection system will be closest to the mark?

More from Matthias Koster
Calculating Aaron Hill’s Expected BABIP
There’s been a lot of talk on how unlucky AHill has been...
Read More
2 replies on “JP Arencibia Receives Johnny Bench Comp”

Comments are closed.