Ranked: The Best Outfield Arms in Blue Jays History

Jesse Barfield

While watching the Toronto Blue Jays play the Baltimore Orioles on Opening Day last week, I saw a tweet by Blue Jays statistician Scott Carson that piqued my interest:

Sure, outfield assist totals aren’t the perfect measure of outfielder arm strength.  Some outfielders with great arms don’t rack up many assists simply because baserunners won’t risk running on them. As soon as a player garners a reputation for having a cannon of an arm, the opportunities to throw out runners dry up like a raisin in the sun.

On the other hand, some outfielders are generally accepted to possess trashbag arms, yet they still rack up the assists.  Take George Bell, for example. While his bat was powerful, his throws from left-field were decidedly average.  As a result, baserunners would try to stretch singles into doubles and be more amenable to tagging-up at third base and trying to score when the ball was hit to Bell.  This meant that George had many, many chances to throw runners out. Sometimes he was successful; Bell racked up 74 outfield assists in 1078 games as a Blue Jay.  As the saying goes, a broken clock is right twice a day.

This got me to thinking: apart from Barfield and Bautista, who are some other Blue Jays outfielders that were known for their throwing arm?  And of those candidates, how would I rank them?

Without further ado, below is my ranking of the all-time greatest Toronto Blue Jays outfield arms:

1. Jesse Barfield

In the six-year period between 1985 and 1990, Jesse Barfield led the league in outfield assists five times. Barfield garnered a reputation early in his career for possessing a cannon of an arm, yet still continued to lead the league year-over-year in outfield assists.

2. Raul Mondesi

Raul Mondesi came to the Blue Jays via trade from the Los Angeles Dodgers in 1999.  Like Barfield, Mondesi’s powerful right arm allowed him to lead the National League in outfield assists in 1995 and 1996.  He then went on to lead the American League in outfield assists while he was with Toronto in 2001.

3. Shawn Green

Green had a monster right-field arm before a shoulder injury relegated it to an ineffective limp noodle.  Although he was never a consistent outfield assist-compiler, he did finish 4th in the American League with Toronto in 1998.  Tragically, I can’t find any footage of Green launching missiles from right-field, but I do fondly remember the sound of jaws dropping onto the Rogers Centre concourse following a Shawn Green throwing display.

Shawn Green
Photo credit: The Toronto Sun files

4. Jose Bautista

Jose Bautista spent most of his career as a third baseman before joining the Blue Jays and transitioning to the outfield.  Like Shawn Green, Bautista never racked up many outfield assists in any particular season, but the strength of his arm was undeniable:

Another common thread between Bautista and Green is that shoulder injuries lessened their outfield effectiveness.  Bautista suffered a severe shoulder strain following an ill-advised throw from right-field to try to nab Delmon Young at first base.

Following that injury, Bautista’s arm hasn’t been the same. He would flip his throws into the infield side-armed and even under-handed. It could be said that he ventured into Shawn Green limp-noodle territory.  However, if opening day was any indication, Bautista’s arm is back to being at least serviceable.  While it remains to be seen if Bautista will ever recapture his former throwing-glory, it appears that at least one Oriole missed the memo that Bautista’s noodle is no longer limp.

5. Moises Sierra

Although Moises Sierra‘s time in Toronto was short (he played in only 97 games over parts of three seasons), the impression he made with his throwing arm was indelible.

6. Alex Rios

The enigmatic Alex Rios had a $1,000,000 arm and a 10-cent head.  Nonetheless, when he put all of his 10-cent head into the game, the results could be outstanding.

7. Candy Maldonado

Candido Maldonado spent most of his baseball-playing career on the west coast.  He became a rental player for the Blue Jays in 1992 and was a key player on that World Series Championship team. Although he was not fleet-of-foot, Maldonado made up for his lack of range with his powerful throwing arm.

Like most rankings, there’s going to be disagreement.  Did I over-hype one player and slight another? Was I too hard on George Bell? Did I leave a deserving player off the list altogether? Let me know in the comments section or @ me on Twitter @callumhughson.

come at me bro

Featured image photo credit: unknown.

Update: Mark Whiten

Thanks to intrepid commenter Matthew Elmslie and a few of you on Twitter who reached out to let me know that I made an egregious error in omitting Mark Whiten from this list. Whiten is best known for hitting four home runs in a single game, albeit as a St. Louis Cardinal.  This hyperbole-filled article from the LA Times states that ‘Whiten’s Arm Is Surpassed Only by His Bat.’  This is faint praise because, apart from his four-home-run-day, Whiten’s bat wasn’t all that impressive over the course of his 11-year career.  Regardless, if I had to add him to the rankings above, I would slot him at 5th all-time, behind Jose Bautista and ahead of Moises Sierra.

Written By

has written for Mopupduty.com since 2006. Follow Callum on Twitter, LinkedIn and Instagram

  • Matthew Elmslie

    I came up with my own list before I read this to see if I could anticipate your thinking. I missed Sierra and Maldonado, but guessed some you didn’t have: Carter, who I didn’t feel strongly about but who I figured had some kind of reputation for a throwing arm; Mark Whiten, who was supposed to have one of the great outfield arms of all time; and George Bell, who _did_ have a good arm before injuries got him.

    • Mark Whiten! I completely forgot about him. He’s a good one. Speaking of players I forgot about: Derek Bell. He likely warrants a mention.

      My recollection of Carter is different than yours; I don’t think his arm was anything special. Another one I thought of was Orlando Merced. He wasn’t in Toronto long, but I think he had a reputation for having a legitimate throwing arm. With that said, my memory of him isn’t strong enough for me to feel confident enough to include him. I do feel bad about giving Bell the gears.