Silvio Garcia: Branch Rickey’s pick to break the colour barrier

When Branch Rickey began began the initiative to break baseball’s colour barrier, he created a shortlist of candidates who he thought had both the playing ability and the character to blaze the trail.  One of them was Cuban Silvio Garcia.

According to Negro League owners and executives, it was Monte Irvin, not Jackie Robinson, who had been first in line on the unofficial list of candidates to integrate baseball.  He likely would have been the first too, had he not passed his draft physical and gone on to serve in World War II.  Rickey then turned his focus to Silvio Garcia.

In the 1940s, when the president of the Brooklyn Dodgers, Branch Rickey, started thinking about bringing a black player to the major leagues, he initially considered the star Cuban shortstop of the day, Silvio García. According to Edel Casas, the noted Cuban baseball historian, Rickey met with García in Havana in 1945 to explore the possibility of bringing the excellent right-handed hitter to the Dodgers. In the course of the interview, Rickey asked García, “What would you do if a white American slapped your face?” García’s response was simple and sincere. “I kill him,” he said.

That ended that conversation, and opened the door for Jackie Robinson.

Garcia still went on to break a colour barrier, although not in the Major Leagues.  On April 9, 1952, Garcia along with teammates George Handy and Angel Scull, broke the colour barrier in the Florida International League when they played for the Miami Beach Flamingos.

Garcia spent most of his career playing in the large shadow cast by compañero Martin Dihigo.  Like Dihigo,  Garcia could both pitch and play shortstop.  In his first season he went 10-2, but finished 2nd in wins to Dihigo.  In 1938 he went to the Mexican League and posted a 1.68 ERA.. trailing only Dihigo.  He gave up pitching in 1940 to focus on shortstop.  He was a bona-fide stud playing in Cuba, Mexico, Puerto Rico and the Negro Leagues.  He was consistently at the top or near the top of the leaderboard in average and doubles. He even played in Canada for the Sherbrooke Athlétiques of the Provincial League, a league that welcomed blacks.  He won the triple crown, especially rare yet even moreso for a shortstop. He led the league in homers (21) doubles (29) and RBI (116).  He hit .365/.435/.608.

Tommy Lasorda is on the record having said that Garcia is the toughest hitter he ever faced in Cuba.

More from Callum Hughson
Live Game Notes & Box Review
Live Game Notes & Box Review For the first time in my...
Read More
5 replies on “Silvio Garcia: Branch Rickey’s pick to break the colour barrier”
  1. says: Early

    This story is seldom told.

    That story is of Black men from the Caribbean or even Canada that went to play in the Negro Leagues. The lack of civil rights must have been shocking to them. While overt racism was a reality around the world at the time the legalised systemic approach of segregation in the USA was not applicable in Canada, Cuba, DR or other places where there is a racial cleavage.

  2. I read that one of the reason’s Garcia phased out of pitching was due mental stress caused by killing a batter with a pitch, according to Echevarria’s ‘Pride of Havana’ book

    1. says: Benjamin Quiñones

      Benjamin Quiñones

      The main reason Silvio Garcia was rejected to break the color barrier was the fact that Branch Rickey found out Silvio has refused to join the Selective Service in his country Cuba.

Comments are closed.