The Atlantic League: Where Former Blue Jays Go To Die

Are you wondering what has happened to your favourite former Toronto Blue Jay? Thinking about what ever happened to that sure-fire can’t miss prospect that never showed up to the big club? Odds are you will find them toiling away in the Atlantic League, an independent professional baseball league for washed up big leaguers.  Let’s see who we find, shall we?

Eric Crozier

Eric Crozier leads the Atlantic League with 8 homeruns.  Crozier was the dud traded straight up for Josh Phelps in 2004.   He made his major league debut with the Blue Jays that season, but was garbage.  In JP Ricciardi’s defense, Josh Phelps never amounted to anything either.

Corey Thurman

Remember when JP would put bullpens together out of released players and Rule 5 draft picks? Corey Thurman was one of those rule 5 draft picks.  Last season, the former Toronto Blue Jay went 4-3 with a 3.28 ERA in 16 starts. That earned run average would have tied for second best in the league given enough innings to qualify, but a freak ailment forced him to miss much of the second half. Thurman returned to the mound late in the year, allowing just one run in nine innings over two starts in September. Nominated to start the All-Star Game for the Freedom Division, “Thurm” allowed only four homeruns in 85.0 innings all season, while walking just 28 batters and striking out 57.

Dan Reichert

I’ve talked about Dan Reichert’s trials and tribulations enough already so I don’t need to re-live the horrors again.  Reichert spent last season with the Bridgeport Bluefish in the Atlantic League, going 14-9 with a 3.53 ERA and 126 strikeouts in 28 starts. He was originally the seventh overall pick in the 1997 draft by the Kansas City Royals, reaching the Majors for the first time in 1999.

John-Ford Griffin

Griffin comes to Newark for his first season after splitting time between Triple-A Iowa and Triple-A Albuquerque in 2009. He hit a combined .250 with 95 hits and 43 RBI for the Cubs and Dodgers affiliates.  The 30-year-old recorded career-bests with the 2005 with Triple-A Syracuse. He grabbed 130 hits, 80 runs, 30 home runs, and 103 RBI. In two major league seasons, he batted .304 with 7 hits and 9 RBI in 23 at-bats. Griffin is also a career .265 hitter in nine minor league seasons with 882 hits and 558 RBI.

This season Griffin is hitting .243 with 4HR in 136 AB in the Atlantic League.

Vito Chiaravalloti

Vito Chiaravalloti was the darling of the Blue Jays minor league system after winning the triple crown in his first professional season, posting a 1.074 OPS for the single-A Auburn Doubledays.  Also it was fun to butcher his name.  Once he moved up to high-A Dunedin, his true colours began to show and those colours were bleak.  For the last 3 seasons Chiaravalloti has been playing in the Atlantic League, posting respectable numbers.

Chiaravalloti played for Somerset during the 2008 season and finished with 78 hits, 17 home runs, and 42 RBI in 102 games played.
He signed with the Camden Riversharks in 2009 and had an All-Star Season where he finished with a .272 batting average, 109 hits, 26 doubles, 12 home runs, and 60 RBI in 119 games played.

Armando Benitez

Former Blue Jays Closer (for a handful of games anyway) Armando Benitez has played the last couple of seasons in the Atlantic League has has found some measure of success.  Benitez enters his second season in the Atlantic League as he spent 2009 with the Bears. He recorded a 1-0 record with a 2.86 ERA and 16 saves, which was third best in the league. The 37-year-old and former Met was signed by the Houston Astros’ AAA affiliate in Round Rock late in the season and went 2-0 with a 3.86 ERA and a save in seven games

Other notable players toiling away in the Atlantic League are:

Scott Spiezio
Sidney Ponson
Antonio Alfonseca
Jorge Julio
Wily Mo Pena
More from Callum Hughson
Help Needed
Help Needed Pictured here is a championship baseball medal from 1921. What...
Read More
2 replies on “The Atlantic League: Where Former Blue Jays Go To Die”
  1. says: jabalong

    Interesting article, thanks!

    Seeing some of the solid numbers in the Atlantic League on some of these guys, got me wondering about players making there making it back to MLB.

    According to the Atlantic League’s website, more than 400 players since 1998 have had their contracts purchased by a major league organization:

    While I realize these players end up in the Atlantic League for a reason, I’d have thought that when they have a great season there, they might get some interest from MLB teams – say for a spring training non-roster invite or something. Have any players from the Atlantic League made it back to the MLB?

  2. says: jabalong

    Doh, that last paragraph of my previous comment was an earlier draft meant to be cut, but don’t see anyway to edit it.

Comments are closed.