Toronto Blue Jays Bullpen


After the pen dropped another game last night, I was left wondering, how has the pen performed as a whole this season?


The Jays bullpen ERA is slightly below AL league average at 3.88 (vs 3.95).

The overall win/loss record is 16 – 18 on the season


Two stats that I’ll use are WPA and WPA/LI.

Following Quotes Via Fangraphs:

WPA is the difference in win expectancy (WE) between the start of the play and the end of the play. That difference is then credited/debited to the batter and the pitcher. Over the course of the season, each players’ WPA for individual plays is added up to get his season total WPA.

LI (leverage index): A measure of how important a particular situation is in a baseball game depending on the inning, score, outs, and number of players on base, created by Tom Tango.

WPA/LI (context neutral wins / game state linear weights): How many wins a player contributes to his team with the Leverage Index aspect removed, invented by Tom Tango.

And more info on WPA/LI , from Tom Tango

As I’ve stated at other occasions, the best stat around is WPA/LI (WPA divided by Leverage Index), which is the same thing as wOBA by Game State. With a man on 3B and less than 2 outs in a close game, a strikeout is a killer. The underlying premise of wOBA is that the average positive value is always exactly 1. That is, a walk is worth on average 0.72 positive plays, but could be worth 0.50 in some cases or as much as 1.00 in the case where a walk and HR are worth exactly the same (bases loaded, tie game, bottom 9th). A HR could be worth as little as 1.0, on average close to 2.0, and probably as high as 3.0 or 4.0. But the point is, we don’t give the leverage to the player. We have a specific wOBA stat for the specific game situation, but, it doesn’t inflate the impact based on the inflated value of the Leverage Index. That’s why it’s WPA divided by LI. From this perspective, sequencing matters, but timing does not….

A typical HR adds around +.13 wins per PA. This particular HR however added +.72 wins. However, his WPA/LI was +.72/10.9 = +.07 wins. This is what the win value of a typical double would be. And, it makes sense. They only needed 2 runs to win, not 4. The effect of the grand slam HR was exactly the same as a two-run single.

For relievers and PH, it’s a bit different, since managers are using them based on the game state. They do have an influence since a better player will implicitly force his manager to use him in the higher leveraged situation. However, as noted Book Blog poster Guy pointed out, those situations will exist regardless of which reliever the manager can choose from. And, he certainly makes a good point. Guy’s idea, why I endorse, is to basically give a portion of the “timing” value to the reliever, a portion of which is based on how much he contributed over what a peer-replacement would have otherwise done. This would satisfy both camps: that part of the “timing” value was strategically earned, and part of it was pure luck.

WPA is a solid overall bullpen stat, while I find WPA/LI to be a better way to gauge closing out games in higher leverage situations.

From an overall Standpoint the Jays Pen is in:

The bottom 3rd in team relief WPA (and 2nd last in the AL, behind only the O’s).

They are in the upper third of the pack in WPA/LI. This makes sense. The Jays pen tends to explode leads, not merely surrender them. This is why the WPA/LI is in the upper thirds vs being down around their WPA rank.

Individual Player Stats


Scott Downs is once again the Jays #1 reliever. Big surprise, eh?

Camp is #2 in WPA but is in the middle of the pack in WPA/LI. This would have to be attributed to some early season middle relief duty, although Camp has given up leads a few times over the past month or so.

Purcey has pitched well and justifies a bump in IP and overall leverage situations.

Gregg’s four blown saves hurt his WPA (which is usually middle range for closers) and shaves some points off of his WPA/LI. His LI leads the team by a wide margin, which is to be expected from the closer.

And for the the record according to WAR values Brian Tallet is the second worst pitcher in all of baseball, responsible for -1.3 wins. His WPA is easily the worst on the club.

The Pen: Overall

On the whole the pen is right around league average. It probably appears to be worse than it is due to

A) the way the Jays can blow larger leads
B) the opponents (losses vs the Yankees and Red Sox stick out more)

More from Matthias Koster
MLB At Bat 11 IPhone App Review
MLB At Bat 11 recently hit the Apple App Store. Here are...
Read More
9 replies on “Toronto Blue Jays Bullpen”
  1. says: Ian

    Great find here K-Man. Overall, I think we’ve been a little spoiled with a stellar bullpen these past few years.

    I know folks like to rip on Gregg, but he hasn’t been nearly as bad as some make him out to be. Like you said, when he blows a save he blows it bigtime.

  2. says: Drew

    What do you think about the bullpen moving forward? WPA and WPA/LI measure the outcome, not the process.

    If a guy like Gregg (or Purcey) flirts with disaster or, worse yet, creates their own mess before escaping; it isn’t reflected in these numbers.

    Do you feel like this is a fair assessment of the skills and abilities of this bullpen?

    1. Re: outcome

      That is true about escaping messes. However, as you say, WPA is outcome (and run based). Inherited runners factor in.

      Also flirting with disaster and escaping, well, their still escaping.


      On the whole this bullpen appears to be on par with the stats, right around league average. Take away Mr. Tallet, who’s -10 runs in only 26 bullpen IP and the bullpen might be a shade above average.

      I think one of the issues is depth. Outside of Purcey, none of the pre-season ‘B’ relievers (Roenicke, Accardo, Janssen, etc) stepped up, statistically speaking.

      Moving Forward: The Jays are going to have to fill some high leverage IP when Downs/Frasor depart. I don’t know if a backend of Gregg/Camp/Purcey is enough to fill the void. The middle of the pen will have to step things up.

  3. says: Alain

    Rag on Gregg, but I would still rather see him run up and at least have a chance to close the came in lieu of BJ.

Comments are closed.