What’s The Deal With Umpire Strike Calls?

What’s The Deal With Umpire Strike Calls?

Watching Brandon Morrow’s last start versus the Tampa Bay Rays, I couldn’t help but notice that CB Bucknor was doing his best Omar Lucero impression.  He was very animated in punching out those Rays hitters who watched strike 3 sail by, but it was the actual strike ‘calls’ that got my attention.

Having watched many games this season, both Blue Jays and out of market games, I can speak to the fact that most umpires have similar strike calls – Vic Carapazza being one of them.

Vic Carapazza

Umpires don’t simply say “strike” or “steeeeerike” like they do in the lower levels.   In a game that prides itself on suppressing the expression of emotion and exuberance, it seems strange that the umpires are the ones who are the most animated on the field.  A called strike three has become a gutteral moan, a form of Primal Therapy that sounds nothing like the word ‘strike’ – “HOOOOOOO HAAAAWWWWW!” Take Tom Hallion, for example.  It sounds like he is being stabbed in the guts with a rusty sword:

How did strike three evolve into THAT?

It actually begins in the mid-level minor leagues.  In umpire school, prospective umpires are taught to focus solely on the fundamentals, but as they advance through the minor league system, their supervisors and trainers actually encourage them to exhibit some panache and flair in their calls.  Umpires are just like the minor league players whose games they call:  if they don’t stand out, they won’t get noticed and therefore won’t receive a promotion to the higher levels.

Fieldin Culbreth

As I mentioned before, in a game where any sort of show of enthusiasm will be misconstrued as “showing up” by sensitive ballplayers, umpires have to toe a fine line or risk being berated by those said ballplayers – even moreso than they normally do.  Of course, those players who include flash as part of their game will respect it when an umpire incorporates it into his.  Says former Toronto Blue Jay Orlando Hudson:

“You can’t feel bad because when we make diving plays we do a little flash, when we hit a home run we do a little flash,” Mr. Hudson said. “The umpires, they’re in the game, too. They have to do a little something, too. That’s their one moment.”

With that said, if you’re going to turn your strike three calls into an intepretive dance art form like CB Bucknor does, you had better be sure that you are getting your calls right.  Bucknor was rated as the worst umpire in all of baseball according to ESPN Magazine in 2010.

Images courtesy of Victor Decolongon/Getty Images and the Associated Press

Written By

has written for Mopupduty.com since 2006. Follow Callum on Twitter, LinkedIn and Instagram

  • vic

    Thanks for researching this topic I always wondered why umpires are so animated compared to referees in other north American sports. It makes one wondered Iis MLB employing the best umpires when they must do a song and dance to get noticed ?

    Speaking of getting noticed why hasnt an umpire try screaming out something incoherent when it is a ball instead of a strike. I always thought they are bias to the pitcher because they only show enthusiam when the pitcher is getting closer to striking out a batter